Comment on TWiT 204: Taste Like Dirt. Lending Kindle books

On This Week in Tech 2004: Taste Like Dirt, Dwight Silverman proposed an interesting idea: to be able to lend books in the Kindle. The book would become unavailable on your Kindle and available on the other person’s Kindle, and after two weeks the book comes back automatically. I don’t think that feature would ever be implemented because it’s not on the publicist best interest.

It would be very simple to have a web app of people lending each other books across the world in a very organized and systematic way. The reason is that there’s no danger for the lender, the book will come back automatically. It’s not the same as lending a real dead tree paper book.

The solution is simple: don’t make it automatic for books to come back. Have the borrower have to press a button to return it. And if the borrower never does then you lose the book. Then you would only lend them to people you trust (not in a p2p-network way) or when you don’t care about losing the book.

What about book swapping? I don’t see a way to implement book swapping without allowing a systematic peer to peer network to exist. That leads me to the issue of DRM, which I’m not going to talk about now.

Reviewed by Daniel Magliola. Thank you!

2 thoughts on “Comment on TWiT 204: Taste Like Dirt. Lending Kindle books

  1. Amazon ha retirado dos obras del autor británico George Orwell de su catálogo de libros electrónicos para el lector Kindle al darse cuenta de que carecía de los derechos para distribuirla. La noticia interesante, sin embargo, es que al eliminarla del catálogo también la borró de los reproductores de los clientes que las habían comprado. Al día siguiente al conectarse los usuarios que habían adquirido “Rebelión en la granja” o “1984” se encontraron con que esos libros habían desaparecido de su lector. Aunque por supuesto Amazon devolvió el dinero los compradores están más que molestos por la intrusión y desaparición de propiedad privada sin su consentimiento. Acaban de descubrir que no son dueños de lo que han comprado.

  2. The point on book swapping sounds interesting… It can be done through an “escrow”… I propose a book to be swapped, you propose yours, and once we both agreed, we both lose our books and gain the others, and you have this third party website in the middle as the trusted “mediator”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.